Monday, February 16, 2009

How democracies fall according to Socrates

How Democracies Become Tyrannies

On the surface, and to most reviewers of Plato's writings, the Republic is a dialogue on justice and on what constitutes the just society. But to careful readers the deeper theme of the Republic is the nature of education and the relationship between education and the survival of the state.
justice and happiness in a community rests upon the moral condition of its citizens
without proper moral conditioning a regime's "defining principle" will be the source of its ultimate destruction. For democracy, that defining principle is freedom. According to Socrates, freedom makes a democracy but freedom also eventually breaks a democracy.
The short version of his theory is that the combination of freedom and poor education in a democracy render the citizens incapable of mastering their impulses and deferring gratification.
Eventually, this uninhibited quest for personal freedom forces the public to welcome the tyrant.
 blog it

In this stage "there is neither order nor necessity in his life, but he calls it pleasant, free, blessedly happy, and he follows it for as long as he lives."
In short, the young man has no anchor, no set of guiding principles or convictions other than his thirst for freedom. His life is aimless, superficial, and gratuitous. The spoiled lotus-eaters of his generation have defined themselves simply by mocking all forms of propriety and prudence. What's worse, as these Athenian baby-boomers exercise their right to vote, they elect "bad cupbearers" as their leaders. The new cupbearers want to stay in office so they give the voters whatever they desire. The public, according to Socrates, "gets drunk by drinking more than it should of the unmixed wine of freedom." Conservative politicians who attempt to mix the wine of freedom with calls for self-restraint "are punished by the city and accused of being accursed oligarchs."
 blog it

"A teacher in such a community is afraid of his students and flatters them, while the students despise their teachers or tutors." Conservatism becomes unpopular just about everywhere, to a point at which even the elderly "stoop to the level of the young and are full of play and pleasantry, imitating the young for fear of appearing disagreeable and authoritarian."
The explosion of boundaries and limits extends even to national identity itself, so that resident aliens and foreigners "are made equal to a citizen."
slavery comes to mean being under any kind of master or limit including the law itself.
The politicians heat up the crowds by vilifying business and wealth and by promising to spread the wealth around. The people then "set up one man as their special champion" and begin "nurturing him and making him great."
 blog it

The people's "special champion" however transforms from leader to tyrant. He "drops hints about the cancellation of debts and the redistribution of land" and continues to "stir up civil wars against the rich." All who have reached this stage, says Socrates, "soon discover the famous request of a tyrant, namely, that the people give him a bodyguard to keep their defender safe for them." The people give him this new security force, "because they are afraid for his safety
After a series of unpopular actions, including stirring up a war in order to generate popular support, the leader begins to alienate some of his closest and most ardent advisers who begin to voice their misgivings in private. Following a purge of these advisors the tyrant attracts some of the worst elements of the city to help him rule.
The citizens finally decide they've had enough and begin to discuss rebellion.
 blog it

First, those of us who are incapable of self-mastery will always shamefully prostrate ourselves before messianic political leaders.
Citizens capable of self-mastery will always choose to be left alone. In other words, they'll always choose limited government.
Second, freedom without limits paves the way to tyranny by undermining respect for the law.
As Socrates warned: extreme freedom will instill a paranoia about any kind of "master" including objective measurements of right and wrong, and of merit based forms of achievement. But when the citizens become enslaved to their vices they'll dutifully cry out for another kind of master.
The ethos of American education has been for many decades saturated with a simple mantra: choice. What's worse, those few remaining educators who chant the old, Socratic mantra of "judgment" are vilified and harassed by the modern day lotus-eaters as hateful conservatives.
But it is judgment not choice that enables a young person to erect a citadel in the soul.
 blog it


Read entire article here.

2 comments:

jinxxxygirl said...

Wow girl what going on with you???Haven't heard about your weightloss and exercise in awhile just political stuff.......so whats up? I know your write about all kinds of things so just wondering how its going with the bike and yoga and your diet. Hope all is well. Jinx!

kris_tea said...

Yeah, I promised myself a while back ago that I would start paying more attention to politics so I can make more informed decisions when it comes to voting.

Tonight is my weigh in so I'll try to post a vid tomorrow or the next day. I recorded a vid today but I had a water leak in my kitchen & got busy with that & didn't get a chance to post it yet. Maybe tomorrow but I may come home & crash in the morning instead due to being up half the day with the leak. :P